Key Points
- A federal judge denied the Havens borrowers’ request for an injunction to stop SAVE plan switches on November 18, 2026, but a ruling on dismissing the case is still to come.
- Two plaintiffs who qualified for forgiveness before 2026 would still owe tax on their discharges, because they didn’t apply to switch plans by December 31, 2025.
- SAVE borrowers should pick a new repayment plan now, and borrowers at the forgiveness timeline should switch to IBR.
The last SAVE plan lawsuit trying to bring back REPAYE lost a major ruling on November 18, 2026. U.S. District Judge Loren L. Alikhan denied the preliminary injunction and stay (PDF File) in Havens v. U.S. Department of Education.
That means the Education Department can keep moving former SAVE borrowers into new repayment plans while the case continues.
The case isn’t over yet. The judge said a separate ruling on the Department’s motion to dismiss will come “in due course.” This ruling also didn’t decide whether REPAYE legally came back when SAVE was struck down. It turned on standing, harm and timing, so the borrowers’ core REPAYE claim is still alive.
Borrowers still shouldn’t plan around a REPAYE comeback, though. When the case was fully briefed in August, we said dismissal was the most likely result, and this ruling points the same way. The plaintiffs had already missed the deadlines that mattered, and the judge’s ruling turned on that timing.
Why Did The Judge Deny The Havens Injunction?
Judge Alikhan found the borrowers didn’t prove irreparable harm, the bar a preliminary injunction has to clear. Two plaintiffs also lacked standing on their student loan tax bomb claims. The court described the remaining harms as “modest increases in monthly payments and unspecified lost interest subsidies.”
The dollar amounts were small. According to the Department of Education’s calculations, Anna Grunseth said her payment would rise $14 a month, and William Boykin put his increase at $49 a month. The Department argued Heather Havens would do better under IBR than REPAYE, and the plaintiffs appeared to concede the point.
Qualifying months weren’t lost either. The plaintiffs acknowledged income-driven repayment forgiveness is still available under IBR, PAYE, ICR and the new Repayment Assistance Plan. They can keep earning months toward discharge after they switch.
The borrower’s own delays hurt the case most. The borrowers asked for an injunction in June 2026, three months after a Missouri court vacated the SAVE rule on March 10. The judge cited rulings calling delays of 44 and 100 days inexcusable. The Missouri court had already rejected the plaintiffs’ request to intervene there as untimely.
Why Can’t These Borrowers Get Tax-Free Forgiveness?
The deadline that mattered was December 31, 2025. The American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) made student loan forgiveness federally tax-free through that date, and the tax-free window closed when Congress didn’t extend it.
Heather Havens says she has 303 qualifying payments on two student loans totaling more than $64,000, with an effective discharge date in late 2025. Elizabeth Robeson says she has 325 qualifying payments on student loans totaling more than $90,000. Both say they qualified for income-driven repayment forgiveness during the tax-free years.
The American Federation of Teachers lawsuit ensured that SAVE borrowers’ discharges were backdated to their eligibility date – if they applied by December 31, 2025 regardless of when the Department of Education processed it. However, because they failed to enroll in an eligible income-driven repayment plan in 2025, they missed their windows. The judge seemed to agree that was a self-imposed issue.
The judge went further. Even if REPAYE came back, both borrowers would still owe tax on a 2026 discharge. Also, the IRS, not the Education Department, has the final say on taxability.
What The Ruling Means By Borrower Situation
Here’s how the ruling applies to the three groups of former SAVE plan borrowers we hear from most.
| Your Situation | What The Ruling Means | What To Do Now |
|---|---|---|
| Still In SAVE Forbearance | Nothing pauses the move to a new repayment plan | Compare RAP and IBR, then apply before your servicer picks Standard for you |
| At Or Past Your Forgiveness Count | A 2026 discharge is federally taxable, with or without REPAYE | Apply for IBR, check insolvency and set money aside for taxes |
| Already Moved To IBR Or RAP | No change | Keep paying and recertify yourself on time |
In the rare case that the judge does allow repay to come back in a future ruling, it won’t block borrowers from enrolling. However, logistically, even if repay was allowed to come back, we don’t know if there’s even time for the Department of Education to re-implement it before the congressionally mandated sunset date of June 30th, 2028.
As such, borrowers really should not be counting on that to be an option in the future, especially after the fact that the preliminary injunction was denied.
What Should SAVE Borrowers Do Now?
Pick a new repayment plan by the date your servicer set. The court won’t stop transfers. Borrowers who don’t choose get placed in the Standard or Tiered Standard Plan, depending on their loan.
Waiting is also costing borrowers money. Interest has accrued on SAVE balances since August 1, 2025, and SAVE forbearance months don’t count toward income-driven repayment forgiveness. Time in SAVE is “buybackable” for PSLF, but that also may not create savings for every borrower – and the timeline is in excess of two years.
Run your monthly payment numbers in our student loan calculator before your servicer chooses for you. Public service workers chasing PSLF should pick between IBR or RAP, whichever plan costs less, and our RAP vs. IBR comparison shows where that crossover sits.
What If You Already Qualify For Forgiveness?
Borrowers past their 240/300 forgiveness count should apply for IBR and let the discharge process. IBR no longer requires a financial hardship, so these borrowers can enroll at any income. The Havens plaintiffs acknowledged they may qualify for cancellation under another income-driven repayment plan.
Borrowers also need to plan for the tax bill. Take a single filer with $50,000 of income and a $64,000 discharge. Using the 2026 federal tax brackets and the $16,100 standard deduction, federal tax rises from about $3,820 to about $16,250. That’s roughly $12,430 in extra taxes.
That figure comes before the insolvency exclusion. It can shrink or erase the bill if your debts exceed your assets right before discharge. You claim it on IRS Form 982, and our tax bomb calculator runs the math with your own balance sheet. Check your state’s tax rules too.
What’s Next In The Havens Case?
The next order is the ruling on the motion to dismiss – meaning the case is done. If the judge grants it, the plaintiffs could appeal to the D.C. Circuit. If the judge denies it, the REPAYE claim moves toward a final decision, while SAVE plan switches keep going. The plaintiffs could also appeal the injunction denial on its own.
For most borrowers, their decision of a new repayment plan never hinged on this case. REPAYE was not the best repayment plan for most borrowers. It had multiple disadvantages and could have been more expensive. One of the borrowers in this case even discovered that.
The planning question stays the same: pick the cheapest plan that keeps your forgiveness path open or choose standard or extended if repayment is your goal.
Editor: Colin Graves
The post SAVE Plan Lawsuit: Judge Denies Bid To Revive REPAYE, What’s Next For Borrowers appeared first on The College Investor.





0 Comments